Menupickcom lists publicly available information. We are not affiliated with the restaurants shown. How we source and check listings
Claim your listing

Menupickcom

Nancy's Pizza O'fallon menu

12 dishes across 5 sections $10 to $20 Pizza Restaurant

Prices transcribed from the printed menu, last checked

Menu Nancy's Pizza O'fallon photo menu 1
Photographed in store, August 2026. See all 4 pages

Photos of the printed menu

Photographed in store in August 2026. The dish list below covers everything we could read clearly; the full card has more.

Nancy's Pizza O'fallon photo menu 1

Salads 6 dishes

  • Chopped Salad $16.15

    Chicken, romaine, radicchio, bacon, tomatoes, parmesan, ditalini pasta, gorgonzola, green onions, carrots, balsamic vinaigrette.

  • Blueberry Pecan Salad $14.75

    Arugula, radicchio, feta, candied pecans, poppy seed dressing.

  • Caesar Salad $13.65

    Romaine, arugula, parmesan, bacon, croutons. Comes with Caesar dressing. Nancy’s favorite!

  • Mixed Green Side Salad $5.50

    Arugula, radicchio, spring mix, parmesan. Comes with balsamic vinaigrette.

  • Caesar Side Salad $7.90

    Romaine, arugula, parmesan, bacon , croutons. Comes with Caesar dressing.

  • Mixed Green Salad $9.50

    Arugula, radicchio, spring mix, parmesan. Comes with balsamic vinaigrette.

Greatest Hits Pizza – Thin 5 dishes

  • Medium Greatest Hits Thin Pizza $21.25

    Enjoy our Classic Thin Crust pizza with one of our recommended topping combinations. Serves 2-3.

  • Large Greatest Hits Thin Pizza $26.60

    Enjoy our Classic Thin Crust pizza with one of our recommended topping combinations. Serves 3-4.

  • Small Greatest Hits Thin Pizza $16.05

    Enjoy our Classic Thin Crust pizza with one of our recommended topping combinations. Serves 1-2.

  • X-Large Greatest Hits Thin Pizza $33.30

    Enjoy our Classic Thin Crust pizza with one of our recommended topping combinations. Serves 4-5.

  • Family Greatest Hits Thin Pizza $40.50

    Enjoy our Classic Thin Crust pizza with one of our recommended topping combinations. Serves 5-6.

Appetizers 8 dishes

  • Garlic Bread $4.50

    Garlic butter and pecorino.

  • Buffalo Blue Waffle Fries $10.80

    Blue cheese dressing, banana peppers, hot buffalo sauce, green onions, and gorgonzola.

  • Italian Breadsticks $4.45

    Garlic butter, pecorino, and marinara.

  • Meatball Trio $13.50

    Roasted meatballs, marinara, garlic, and spinach.

  • Bone-In Chicken Wings $11.60

    Choose nancy's sweet bbq, hot buffalo or memphis bbq. served with blue cheese or ranch dressing.

  • Parmesan Pesto Waffle Fries $10.80

    Pesto aioli, parmesan, balsamic glaze, and fresh basil.

  • Boneless Chicken Wings $11.40

    Choose nancy's sweet bbq, hot buffalo or memphis bbq. served with blue cheese or ranch dressing.

  • Bacon Caesar Waffle Fries $9.60

    Caesar dressing, bacon, parmesan, and green onions.

Sandwiches 5 dishes

  • Roasted Italian Beef $9.95

    Italian bread and au jus.

  • The Godfather $11.75

    Garlic bread, roasted Italian beef, mozzarella, and au jus.

  • The Godmother $11.75

    Breaded chicken, garlic bread, marinara, and mozzarella. Nancy’s favorite!

  • Roasted Chicken Pesto $11.75

    Garlic bread, pesto aioli, mozzarella, arugula, and balsamic vinaigrette.

  • Italian Meatball Sub $11.75

    Garlic bread, roasted meatballs, mozzarella, and marinara.

Pizza – Stuffed 3 dishes

  • 12" Large Original Stuffed Pizza $34.90

    The stuffed pizza is 2 1/2 inches high and features two layers of crust stuffed with cheese and toppings and covered with our perfectly spiced sauce. Serves 4-5.

  • 9" Small Original Stuffed Pizza $23.60

    The stuffed pizza is 2 1/2 inches high and features two layers of crust stuffed with cheese and toppings and covered with our perfectly spiced sauce. Serves 2-3.

  • 10" Medium Original Stuffed Pizza $27.60

    The stuffed pizza is 2 1/2 inches high and features two layers of crust stuffed with cheese and toppings and covered with our perfectly spiced sauce. Serves 3-4.

Pastas 5 dishes

  • Baked Rigatoni $16.75

    Roasted tomatoes, spinach, Italian sausage, and melted mozzarella. Choose from our classic marinara or try our new meat sauce!

  • Fettuccine Alfredo $11.60

    Cream, parmesan, and parsley. Nancy’s favorite!

  • Spaghetti & Meatballs $16.75

    Three roasted meatballs, parmesan, and basil. Choose from our classic marinara or try our new meat sauce!

  • Tuscan Rigatoni $16.40

    Italian sausage, mushrooms, garlic, and tomato cream.

  • Baked Chicken Tetrazzini $16.75

    Cream, parmesan, mushrooms, and melted mozzarella.

Sides 5 dishes

  • Side Of Dressing $1.25

  • Side Of Sauce $1.25

  • Side Of Meatballs $6.50

    2 meatballs with marinara.

  • Side Of Waffle Fries $3.50

    Nearly a pound of fries

  • Side Of Italian Sausage $6.50

    With marinara.

Desserts 1 dishes

  • Classic Cannoli $3.20

    Ricotta cream and chocolate chips. Nancy’s favorite!

Pizza - Gluten-Free 1 dishes

  • Medium Gluten-Free Thin Crust $18.30

    While we offer a gluten-free pizza crust, our kitchen is not a gluten-free environment.

Beverages 3 dishes

  • Beverage (2 Liter) $3.95

    We offer a variety of flavors.

  • Bottled Water $1.49

    Crisp, cool, refreshing.

  • Beverage (20 Oz) $2.90

    We offer a variety of flavors.

Pizza – Thin 5 dishes

  • 16" X - Large Classic Thin Crust Pizza $27.30

    “A tried and true classic. Crispy around the edges and cheese caramelized to perfection”.Serves 4-5.

  • 18" Family Classic Thin Crust $33.50

    “A tried and true classic. Crispy around the edges and cheese caramelized to perfection”. Serves 5-6.

  • 12" Medium Classic Thin Crust Pizza $16.25

    “A tried and true classic. Crispy around the edges and cheese caramelized to perfection”.Serves 2-3.

  • 10" Small Classic Thin Crust Pizza $11.65

    “A tried and true classic. Crispy around the edges and cheese caramelized to perfection”. Serves 1-2.

  • 14" Large Classic Thin Crust Pizza $21.10

    “A tried and true classic. Crispy around the edges and cheese caramelized to perfection”. Serves 3-4.

Greatest Hits Pizza – Stuffed 3 dishes

  • Medium Greatest Hits Stuffed Pizza $33.20

    Enjoy our Original Stuffed pizza with one of our recommended topping combinations. Serves 3-4.

  • Small Greatest Hits Stuffed Pizza $28.40

    Enjoy our Original Stuffed pizza with one of our recommended topping combinations. Serves 2-3.

  • Large Greatest Hits Stuffed Pizza $41.10

    Enjoy our Original Stuffed pizza with one of our recommended topping combinations. Serves 4-5.

About these prices

Restaurants change prices without notice, and a menu photographed in August may already be out of date. Treat these figures as a guide, not a quote. If you spot a difference, tell us and we will re-check it.

Nancy's Pizza O'fallon is a cozy spot where the aroma of freshly baked pizza immediately hits you the moment you walk in. Known for its comforting, hearty dishes, this pizza restaurant really leans into that “made-for-you” feel, offering everything from classic cheesy slices to loaded specialty pies that make each bite satisfying. The menu isn’t just about pizza, either-there’s a range of comfort food favorites that pair perfectly with a casual night out or a relaxed meal at home. Whether you prefer to enjoy your order in the restaurant or take it on the go, Nancy's Pizza O'fallon makes it easy with options like curbside pickup, no-contact delivery, full delivery service, takeout, and traditional onsite dining. The vibe is casual and inviting, making it a go-to for families, friends, or anyone craving a slice of something warm and flavorful. Service is friendly and quick, which pairs well with the menu’s mix of hearty pizzas and classic comfort dishes, making it easy to satisfy a late-night craving or plan a relaxed dinner. Even for first-time visitors, the combination of flexible service, comforting menu, and welcoming atmosphere ensures that you feel right at home, whether you’re indulging in a cheesy favorite or trying something new from their variety of comfort options. It’s one of those places that balances convenience with the familiar pleasure of a well-made pizza, keeping things simple but consistently satisfying.

Other menus in O'Fallon

Prices transcribed the same way, each with the date last checked.

All O'Fallon listings
Call Menu Directions